The benefits and disadvantages of the american policy of containment

.

The benefits and disadvantages of the american policy of containment

Bernstein The containment doctrine, with its ambiguities and imprecision, was a major strategy and the guiding conception in American foreign policy from shortly after World War II until the collapse of the Soviet Union in —, and some might argue that containment remained a policy into the twenty-first century for the United States in dealing with communist regimes in CubaNorth Koreaand China.

Containment

In its most general form, containment denotes the American effort, by military, political, and economic means, to resist communist expansion throughout the world. But precisely because of the looseness of the doctrine and the differing interpretations, including questions about the selective application of efforts to stop communism, the doctrine's author, George F.

Kennan, an influential foreign service officer in and later a respected private scholar, often opposed important tactics that many American policymakers defined as the implementation of containment: As Kennan stated in If … I was the author in of a "doctrine" of containment, it was a doctrine that lost much of its rationale with the death of Stalin and with the development of the Soviet-Chinese conflict.

I emphatically deny the paternity of any efforts to invoke that doctrine today in situations to which it has, and can have, no proper relevance. While agreeing on the desirability of resisting communist expansion, Kennan and others disagreed on whether the doctrine remained relevant, and how and where to implement it.

Their disputes have often rested on fundamental differences about the capacity of American power, about the extent of American interests beyond western Europe, and especially about the nature of the communist threat.

The last issue has raised many questions.

The benefits and disadvantages of the american policy of containment

Was the threat subversion, revolution, military aggression, economic encirclement, or some combination? With the exception of Yugoslaviawas world communism controlled by Joseph Stalin even after the successful Chinese revolution in ?

After the death of Joseph Stalin in and after the obvious Sino-Soviet split in the early s, did the nature of the communist threat sometimes change, even well before the collapse of the Soviet Union in —?

At times from the early s, according to the proponents of containment, was the threat primarily China and wars of national liberation in the Third Worldand not the Soviet Union mostly in the developed world?

Was American policy in the s and continuing into the twenty-first century in dealing with Cuba, North Koreaand the People's Republic of China often the policy of containment?

Report Abuse

Beyond these important issues, scholars, as well as politicians and policymakers, have raised other questions: Many of the questions about containment, if it is interpreted as the general course of American foreign policy, become the basic questions about that policy itself, from Harry S.

Truman's administration to the first years of President George H. Bush's and possibly beyond.

Works Cited Issues over Containment Policy: America had one major goal throughout the Cold War, to stop the spread of communism.
Containment | leslutinsduphoenix.com Bernstein The containment doctrine, with its ambiguities and imprecision, was a major strategy and the guiding conception in American foreign policy from shortly after World War II until the collapse of the Soviet Union in —, and some might argue that containment remained a policy into the twenty-first century for the United States in dealing with communist regimes in CubaNorth Koreaand China.

.

.

That mid statement, it might be said, became the near-canonical expression of containment, though Kennan himself, even in the s when operating in the State Department, provided various formulations in speeches and reports that departed, sometimes, significantly from the essay.

When his identity quickly leaked out, his Mr. Truman's call on 12 Marchin the so-called "Truman Doctrine" speech, for economic and military aid "to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures.

Such a policy "must be … long-term, patient but firm and vigilant. Containment promised the liberation of Eastern Europe and an American victory in the long run, without preventive war.

Containment Policy - Hidden Perspective on the Korean War

History was on the side of the West.The policy of containment, in addition to the effect of the Marshall Plan developed a structure with which the loosely felt, yet unavoidable tensions were spiraling within Europe in the mid Conclusion The Truman Doctrine was generally a reaction to political issues in Greece, but later had an impact in Europe and the entire world.

Apr 10,  · Containment was the U.S.

goal of the Cold War. The idea was to prevent the spread of Communism outside of the areas it already was in place. That policy is credited to an American Diplomat named (I believe) George leslutinsduphoenix.com: Resolved.

It looks like you've lost connection to our server. Please check your internet connection or reload this page.

The benefits and disadvantages of the american policy of containment

Conclusion Advantages and Disadvantages Overall, the Truman Doctrine had both advantages and disadvantages. The Truman Doctrine and the Development of American Foreign Policy during the era of the “Cold War” defined foreign policy. It was a major break %(1).

Issues over Containment Policy: America had one major goal throughout the Cold War, to stop the spread of communism. A major foreign policy that the US promoted throughout the 20th century was called Containment. Many of the questions about containment, if it is interpreted as the general course of American foreign policy, become the basic questions about that policy itself, from Harry S.

Truman's administration to the first years of President George H. W. Bush's and possibly beyond.